Contact Us →

Avoiding Medicare Penalties: Navigating Challenges with PharmD Live® Solutions

Published: Revised:
Healthcare clinicians reviewing clinical information on a tablet and laptop in a medical setting

Medicare’s strict focus on quality performance metrics places direct financial pressure on outpatient practices and health systems.

Under current Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) regulations, MIPS performance can lead to payment adjustments of up to -9% for eligible clinicians’ covered professional services; a separate hospital program addresses excess readmissions.

For medical group leaders and ACO executives, these distinct payment and quality requirements can create financial and operational pressure.

To support quality performance and manage financial risk, forward-thinking medical organizations are deploying virtual clinical pharmacists.

Working alongside the existing care team, virtual pharmacists can identify medication adherence barriers and help coordinate follow-up.

Understanding Medicare Quality Programs and Benchmarks

Medicare quality and payment requirements vary across programs. Three frameworks relevant to many organizations are:

  1. Merit-Based Incentive Payment System (MIPS): Adjusts Medicare Part B payments across four categories, generally weighted in 2026 traditional MIPS as Quality (30%), Cost (30%), Promoting Interoperability (25%), and Improvement Activities (15%), subject to CMS reweighting rules when a category does not apply.

For Performance Year (PY) 2026, clinicians generally need a final score of at least 75 points to avoid a negative adjustment in Payment Year 2028 (a specialty-specific Core Measure requirement begins in PY 2027, not 2026).

  1. Medicare Advantage (MA) Star Ratings: Rates MA-PD health plan contracts on quality measures, including Part D medication adherence for RAS antagonists, statins, and diabetes therapies (each weight 3 in both 2026 and 2027 Star Ratings).

A Proportion of Days Covered (PDC) of at least 80% is the individual member adherence threshold, not the plan’s Star cut point, while overall plan ratings govern CMS Quality Bonus eligibility and any separate provider contract incentives.

  1. Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs): Under CMS’s Medicare Shared Savings Program (MSSP), ACOs must clear both a financial gate (reducing Part A/B spending below benchmark by at least the Minimum Savings Rate) and a quality gate (reporting the 2026 APP Plus measure set and meeting CMS’s quality performance standard) to earn full shared savings.

The Financial Impact of Quality Performance

Failing to meet Medicare quality benchmarks can affect future payments, particularly for practices operating on thin operating margins:

  • Clinician Part B Reductions (MIPS): Falling below the 75-point threshold results in penalties of up to -9%.

For illustration, a 9% reduction to $5 million in eligible Medicare-paid amounts would be $450,000; actual impact depends on the applicable adjustment and payment base.

  • Hospital Readmission Penalties: Separate from clinician MIPS, CMS’s Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program (HRRP), evaluates eligible acute care hospitals on excess 30-day readmissions for six specified conditions and procedures, capping penalties at 3% of Medicare fee-for-service base operating DRG payments (not all Part A payments).

  • Forfeited ACO Shared Savings: Shared savings depend on the specific program or contract, including applicable quality and financial requirements.

Quality performance may affect whether and how much an ACO earns.

PharmD Live®: How Pharmacists Support Quality and Revenue Goals

Tracking quality measures and coordinating outreach can be challenging for busy clinic teams.

Without a coordinated process for tracking gaps and outreach, practices may have less time to address quality measures before reporting deadlines.

Pharmacist-led care management, working alongside the existing care team, can support follow-up between clinic visits and quality improvement efforts:

PharmD Live® combines pharmacist-led care with technology-enabled workflows to support practices’ quality goals:

1. Optimizing Clinical Quality Measures

Our Pharmacist Care Managers (PCMs) work directly with your patient panel to support care and quality efforts:

  • Medication Adherence: PCMs can help identify adherence barriers and provide coaching in coordination with the care team.

  • Chronic Condition Control: Targeted pharmacist interventions may support blood pressure and diabetes management in coordination with the treating clinician.

  • Readmission Prevention: Post-discharge outreach and medication reconciliation can support safer transitions and may help reduce avoidable readmissions.

2. Streamlining Practice Operations

PharmD Live® reduces administrative friction for clinic staff by managing non-face-to-face quality care tasks:

  • Native EHR Write-Backs: Clinical notes and care-gap information can be shared through agreed EHR and documentation workflows.

  • Documentation Support: Care management logs can support the practice’s billing and reporting workflows.

Strategic Quality & Financial Value Matrix

Integrating pharmacist-led care management can support quality performance and value-based care goals:

Program Area Clinical Focus Financial & Operational Benefit
Program AreaMIPS Optimization Clinical FocusQuality & Cost category management Financial & Operational BenefitAvoids up to -9% payment penalties and qualifies for positive performance adjustments.
Program AreaMedicare Advantage Stars Clinical FocusMedication adherence measures (PDC at least 80% for eligible members) Financial & Operational BenefitSupport adherence measures; plan ratings and payments depend on multiple factors.
Program AreaACO Shared Savings Clinical FocusCare coordination and transitions support Financial & Operational BenefitMay support total-cost-of-care goals; shared savings depend on program rules and performance.

A Clear Path to Long-Term Success

Meeting Medicare’s evolving quality standards requires a workflow suited to the practice, its resources, and the applicable program.

PharmD Live® offers pharmacist-led, multidisciplinary care management alongside existing care teams to support quality and value-based care goals.

Contact PharmD Live® to discuss your care management and quality priorities.

References

  1. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). Calendar Year (CY) 2026 Quality Payment Program (QPP) Final Rule. CMS.gov.

  2. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program (HRRP) Overview & Technical Notes. CMS HRRP.

  3. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). CMS Finalizes CY 2027 Physician Fee Schedule to Shift from Sick Care to Healthcare and Curb Waste.

  4. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). Medicare Shared Savings Program: Program Guidance & Specifications.

  5. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). 2027 Medicare Advantage and Part D Star Ratings Measures.

  6. Cutler RL, Fernandez-Llimos F, Frommer M, Benrimoj C, Garcia-Cardenas V. Economic impact of medication non-adherence by disease groups: a systematic review. BMJ Open. 2018;8(1):e016982. doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2017-016982. PMID: 29358417.

  7. Tenpas AS, Vascimini A, et al. Improvement in Clinical Outcomes and Access to Care With Pharmacist-Led Chronic Care Management Services at a Rural Family Medicine Clinic. J Pharm Pract. 2023 Dec;36(6):1392-1396. doi: 10.1177/08971900221118232. PMID: 35938485.

  8. PharmD Live®. Quality Compliance & Chronic Care Management Solutions. PharmD Live.

Cynthia C. Nwaubani, PharmD, BCGP & Divine C. Gama, BPharm
Stay Informed

Subscribe for More Insights

Get valuable clinical and healthcare resources delivered straight to your inbox.